🏉 PANTHERS FANS, IT’S TIME TO SETTLE THE DEBATE! WHO DESERVES TO BE PENRITH’S GREATEST PROP: MOSES LEOTA, PETERO CIVONICEVA OR TIM GRANT? 💙🐾
Every successful rugby league team needs powerful forwards who can win the battle through the middle, create momentum and give their teammates the platform to shine. For the Penrith Panthers, the club’s history includes some memorable big men who have made their mark in different eras.
But here comes the question that could divide Panthers supporters: if you had to rank Moses Leota, Petero Civoniceva and Tim Grant from first to third, who would come out on top?
My personal ranking is clear:
🥇 1. Moses Leota
🥈 2. Petero Civoniceva
🥉 3. Tim Grant
That is my order, but it certainly does not mean every Panthers supporter will agree. Each player brings a different story, a different style and a different contribution to the club.
So, let’s take a closer look at why this debate deserves attention.
💥 1. Moses Leota — The modern-day powerhouse
For me, Moses Leota takes the top spot.
Leota has become a familiar and important presence in Penrith’s forward pack, bringing aggression, physicality and relentless effort through the middle. His style is built around making hard metres, challenging opposing defenders and helping the Panthers establish control in the forward battle.
A prop’s contribution is not always measured by the number of spectacular moments he produces. Sometimes, the most important work happens in the less glamorous parts of a match: taking the ball into contact, absorbing pressure, getting the team moving forward and forcing the opposition to work hard defensively.
That is where Leota’s role becomes so valuable.
Penrith’s success in recent years has been built on teamwork, discipline and a powerful forward platform. While the outside backs and playmakers often receive attention for their tries and match-winning moments, the work of the middle forwards helps make those opportunities possible.
Leota has developed into one of the recognisable figures in that system. His physical approach gives Penrith a strong presence in the middle, while his willingness to compete helps maintain the intensity required at the highest level.
For supporters who value a prop’s impact on the team’s overall performance, Leota has a compelling case.
However, ranking him first is a personal judgement rather than an undisputed historical fact. Supporters who prioritise longevity, achievements across different clubs or contributions over a longer period may come to a different conclusion.
That is what makes this comparison interesting.
Is Moses Leota the best of these three, or does another name deserve the number-one position?
🏆 2. Petero Civoniceva — A respected name in rugby league
Petero Civoniceva takes second place in my ranking, but that should not be mistaken for a lack of respect.
Civoniceva is one of the most respected forwards of his generation. Across a distinguished career, he earned a reputation for strength, professionalism and consistency, representing Queensland and Australia while also playing for multiple NRL clubs.
His career included time with the Brisbane Broncos, Penrith Panthers and South Sydney Rabbitohs. He also played a significant role in Queensland’s State of Origin success and represented Australia on the international stage.
Those achievements give Civoniceva a strong argument in any discussion about outstanding props associated with Penrith.
He was not simply a player who relied on size and strength. His value also came from his consistency and his ability to perform in demanding matches. For a forward, earning the trust of coaches and teammates over many seasons is an achievement in itself.
Civoniceva’s experience also provides an interesting contrast with Leota.
The two played in different eras, under different tactical conditions and within different team environments. Rugby league has evolved considerably, including changes in speed, interchange strategies and the physical demands placed on middle forwards.
That makes a direct comparison difficult.
Some Panthers fans may argue that Civoniceva should be ranked first because of his outstanding career and achievements. Others may favour Leota because of his contribution to the modern Penrith side.
Both positions can be argued, depending on what a supporter values most.
For my list, Civoniceva sits at number two, but he is certainly not an easy player to place below anyone.
🔥 3. Tim Grant — A name Panthers fans should remember
Tim Grant completes my top three.
Grant may not always dominate conversations about the greatest forwards in rugby league, but he remains a name worth including when discussing Penrith’s props.
He represented the Panthers during important periods in the club’s modern history and was known for his work in the middle of the field. His career also included opportunities elsewhere in the NRL, giving him experience across different teams and playing environments.
Ranking Grant third does not mean his contribution should be dismissed. A prop’s value often extends beyond statistics, highlight reels and individual awards.
Forwards are asked to perform demanding tasks repeatedly throughout a match. They must make difficult carries, defend against powerful opponents, recover quickly and maintain their intensity even when fatigue sets in.
Their work can be crucial to the team’s performance without always attracting the same attention as a try-scoring winger or a creative halfback.
Grant deserves recognition as part of the wider story of Penrith’s forward stocks.
Still, when comparing these three players, I place him third behind Leota and Civoniceva.
That ranking is open to debate, and supporters who remember Grant’s performances particularly fondly may have him much higher.
After all, every fan has different memories of the players who have represented their club.
⚖️ So, how should Panthers fans rank them?
This is where the conversation becomes particularly interesting.
Should the ranking be based on individual ability? Overall career achievements? Performances in a Panthers jersey? Consistency across multiple seasons? Or the impact each player had on the team’s success?
Those questions can produce very different lists.
If you focus on overall career achievements, Civoniceva has a particularly strong case. If you value the physical demands and contributions of Penrith’s modern forward pack, Leota may be your preferred choice. If you remember Grant’s time at the club and believe his contribution deserves more recognition, you might put him above both.
There is no single measurement that settles every historical comparison.
What matters is that all three names offer Panthers supporters something different to discuss.
And that’s part of the fun of following rugby league. Fans can watch the same players, remember the same matches and still come away with completely different opinions.
💙 YOUR TURN, PANTHERS FANS!
My final order remains:
🥇 Moses Leota
🥈 Petero Civoniceva
🥉 Tim Grant
But I want to know what you think.
Would you put Civoniceva at number one because of his remarkable career? Does Leota deserve the top spot for his role in Penrith’s modern forward pack? Or have I ranked Tim Grant too low?
And if you could add another Panthers prop to this conversation, who would it be?
👇 COMMENT YOUR TOP THREE IN ORDER!
No need to agree with my list — make your case, defend your favourite and let other Panthers fans have their say.
Let’s see which prop comes out on top when the Penrith faithful make their voices heard! 🐾💙🏉






